• Home
  • Blog
  • Creating a more sustainable Shetland
By Promote ShetlandFebruary 5th 2021

Alex Armitage recently moved to Bigton from London with his wife Deepa and their seven-year-old son. As well as being a trained paediatrician, Alex has a keen interest in ecology and food production, particularly in the context of the climate emergency. In his first blog post for Shetland.org, he writes about the importance of food security in the islands.

Last week I visited JK Mainland Farm at Brake, a few miles from where we live in the south mainland of Shetland. Until one month ago we lived in London where I was involved for 10 years setting up and running community vegetable gardens on our council estate in Dalston, so I am eager to learn about food growing in Shetland, albeit at a larger scale and in a different climate.

As a paediatrician, I have a professional interest in food. Good nutrition is the foundation of child heath – working in South Africa and London I have witnessed the long term detrimental effects that malnutrition has on people’s lives. Food is a basic human need and it’s vital that we protect our systems of food production and supply. In recent years, with the advent of foodbanks and recent scandals over free school meals and food boxes, it is clear that even in Britain, these systems are beginning to crumble.

The landscape in Shetland is windswept with little shelter – as a first time visitor it would be hard to imagine anything growing here at all except for grass. In fact, food does grow well in Shetland, despite the high winds and salt spray from the sea. In 1861 over 31,000 people lived here and all of the calories that sustained the population then were either grown from the land or caught from the sea. In contrast, the calories that sustain today’s population of 23,000 mainly come via the supermarkets and wholesalers in Lerwick: perhaps cheaper financially - but at the environmental cost of plastic packaging, shipping, road transport, soil degradation and an uncertain and unsustainable future.

A few days prior to Christmas in 2012, after just two days of cancelled ferries due to high winds, Shetland’s supermarket shelves were emptying. In response, Tesco chartered a C130 Hercules transporter plane to make emergency deliveries of food before Christmas. What was seen as a sign of strength by many was in fact an act of desperation to cover up a weak food supply system, exposed by Shetland’s remote geographical location.

Fast forward exactly eight years to 2020 and Kevin Obern, the farmer at J K Mainland, has been causing a stir with his popular Christmas veg boxes, which contained enough food to feed a family of four for two weeks. For £27.50, Shetland residents got, delivered to their door, three turnips as big as your head, 1kg sprouts, three cabbages (white, green and savoy), 3kg carrots and 15kg potatoes, including 2kg of Shetland black tatties, a local heritage variety, which is not normally commercially available. Shetland blacks are actually purple skinned – but if you cut one open the flesh is white, with a purple ring just below the surface of the skin.

During the Covid pandemic, Kevin’s vegetable box deliveries have enabled more Shetlanders to access healthy, local vegetables – without the risk of infection associated with visiting the supermarket.

Kevin’s family has been proudly supplying the Shetland supermarkets with carrots, neeps and tatties for decades but has always had to compete with farmers outwith Shetland that farm on a more industrial scale A trip around the fruit and vegetable aisles today reveals a large quantity of vegetables that can easily be grown in Shetland but instead get imported from the UK mainland and Europe.

British farming is in trouble. In the second half of the 20th century, traditional farming methods became frowned upon as “advancements” in agricultural technology such as new pesticides, genetically modified seeds, fertilisers and more powerful farm machinery enabled arable farmers to increase their short term yields – but at the price of poor soil quality, biodiversity reduction, dwindling populations of insect pollinators and soil erosion. Ecosystems we all depend on have been destroyed in front of our very eyes.

UK farmers, forced into submission by the power of the supermarkets, have become snared by an ecologically and economically unsustainable system, having no option but to take out huge bank loans to pay for the agricultural technology that is driving ecological destruction.

Food production, once an essential activity that brought communities together has become an isolated endeavour. Pressure on prices from supermarkets has meant that food production has lost economic viability, with many livelihoods dependent on government subsidy. Many farmers have been driven to debt and despair. It’s no wonder that so many suffer from poor mental health, with suicide rates in farmers being amongst the highest of any occupational group.

The J K Mainland farm is fighting this system. By harnessing Shetlanders’ addiction to social media, Kevin has built up an enthusiastic Facebook following and has found that by bypassing the supermarkets there is a real living to be made in growing vegetables. He now employs two workers full time on the farm, with more employment at harvest time. Next year he plans double the carrot crop as well as increase variety, with a wider range of crops such as beetroot and red cabbage in addition to broccoli, kale and the other traditional Shetland vegetables. Kevin has already agreed to supply vegetables to other small businesses in Shetland, and spoke of teaming up with other local producers to expand the variety of food delivered in his boxes. When I broached the awkward subject of farm subsidy, I was surprised to hear that the farm receives close to nothing, with Kevin advocating for the removal of farm subsidies altogether.

We arrived at the farm just after 3pm as the January skies were darkening, with snow on the higher hills and temperatures close to zero. Kevin took us up to the fields enthusiastically explaining the traditional methods of managing the land, rotating the crops each year order to maintain soil health and avoid the worst pests and diseases from taking hold. It was amazing to see such healthy green savoy cabbages in the field, and the carrots were the biggest I’ve ever seen. There is little waste too, with broccoli stems going to feed the chickens, and sheep eating the lower quality turnips. When we arrived home later, you could taste the difference in the quality of the cabbage and carrots, which had literally been in the ground an hour earlier.

For the whole of human history, with exception of the last 70 years, ordinary people have been highly engaged with the production and preparation of food. The last two generations have seen society taken over by fast fashion, fast food, fast cars: a system of consumerist economic growth driven by the burning of fossil fuels. This system has separated us from our food systems and communities and created new threats to our physical and mental health. Food, Society, Health, Nature… everything is interconnected.

Feeding a rapidly expanding global population, forecast for almost 10 billion in 2050, will be one of the biggest challenges of the 21st century. Our fragile food systems, themselves responsible for more than a quarter of all greenhouse gas emissions, are extremely vulnerable to climate change, with yields of the four crops that constitute two thirds of human calorific intake; wheat, maize, rice and soya, falling significantly with just a few degrees of warming.

If the 20th century was about economic growth, then the 21st century needs to be about sustainability – yet it’s 2021 and we find ourselves 21 years behind schedule. Technological advancements can help - but on their own won’t save us. We need to reject the consumerism of the recent past and reconnect with communities, with our natural environment and with the soil. Many more of us will need to get directly involved in the production of food.

As a child, I clearly remember my Shetland Grandmother lamenting how her way of life had been unsanctimoniously devoured by ‘progress’. “It’s aa aboot money money money” she used to tell me, with a powerless shake of her head. At least now some people are beginning to heed my Granny’s warning.

Although it’s not a totally organic farm, J K Mainland is a leading light towards a more sustainable future for Shetland. By offering a tangible alternative to the dominance of supermarkets, Kevin, with his ideas, energy and enthusiasm, is reconnecting Shetlanders with our land and culture, strengthening our food security and showing that a better, more sustainable world is possible.